Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Heather Brenner's avatar

1. Home postal delivery is efficient in densely populated areas. In rural areas, it is grossly inefficient for the most part. Definitely far LESS efficient than communicating via cell phone. Yes, the act of writing letters is efficient. Transporting them is far less efficient than sending bytes of data via radio waves. I live in a spread out rural, offgrid, neighborhood. Terrain dictates that no one is driving faster than about 20mph. If I had to physically take messages every time I needed to talk to a neighbor, it would get real unworkable real fast, even with the ability to send a kid on an atv with the message. Coms up here are generally via text, where there is cell service or satellite internet on both ends, walkie talkie or send a kid where there is not.

(I have both texts and emails that I cherish)

6. Good idea, in general. There are plenty of companies willing to supply such co-ops. Azure Standard is the one we use. I facilitate our neighborhood's order, and we cooperate on meeting the truck and bringing stuff back. For us, most shopping is 75 miles, which takes 2 hours. There is NO "run to the store". Being willing to grab something from a store for your neighbor, pick up someone's mail, etc, is also huge. It reduces trips, makes everyone's life easier, and builds community.

8. Trains and ships are the best way to transport cargo long distances. For passenger transit, they are only efficient if schedules are sufficiently convenient and passengers within walking distance. If I have to drive 50 miles, take a train 100 miles, and then have someone pick me up at the other end, trains get real inefficient real fast. When it comes to transporting people quickly over long distance, trains require much more infrastructure than planes, and that infrastructure must be impeccably maintained, every mile of it. Passenger rail only approaches being self supporting where population densities are very high.

Expand full comment
4 more comments...

No posts